How to Decide Who Gets What: Asset Division Simplified
- Jodie Graham
- Apr 20
- 5 min read
Updated: 4 days ago
Let’s be real. Nobody dreams of the day they’ll be divvying up patio furniture and pension plans. When you first build a life with someone, the last thing on your mind is how to fairly split it all up if things go sideways. But when divorce enters the picture, those shared assets big and small suddenly become decision points. Who gets the car? What about the RESP? And please, let’s not fight over the air fryer.
It’s no wonder that asset division is one of the most stressful parts of separation. You're dealing with emotional baggage and financial decisions at the same time. But here’s the good news. You can make it simpler.
And in the words of Leonardo da Vinci, “Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.” That might sound like something you'd find stitched on a throw pillow, but in the context of a divorce, it’s solid advice. The simpler and clearer your approach, the smoother this part of the process becomes. No drama. No dragging things out unnecessarily. Just a clean, respectful division so everyone can move forward.
Whether you’re parting ways peacefully or tensions are high, this guide will walk you through how to tackle asset division in divorce without losing your mind or your blender. We'll talk about how to categorize your assets, understand the legal framework in Canada, and keep your cool when disagreements flare up.
Because while divorce property settlement isn’t usually anyone’s idea of fun, it doesn’t have to be a mess. With a bit of structure and a focus on what really matters, you can turn a complicated process into something manageable.
Step 1: Categorizing Assets – What’s In the Mix?
Before anyone starts laying claim to the espresso machine or the snowblower, take stock of what you actually have. Categorizing your assets helps you see the full picture and it’s a crucial first step in making smart decisions.
1. Marital vs. Separate Property
In most Canadian provinces, anything acquired during the marriage is considered marital property. That includes the house, cars, savings accounts, and even points on your travel rewards card. Yes, even those can be up for grabs.
Separate property typically includes assets one partner owned before the marriage, as well as gifts or inheritances received individually. But watch out. If that inheritance ended up in a joint account or was used for a shared purchase, it may have become fair game.
2. Physical Stuff vs. Financial Assets
It’s easy to get caught up in who gets the couch, but don’t sleep on the less visible assets. Think:
Bank accounts
RRSPs and TFSAs
Pensions and benefits
Investments
Business assets
Also, don’t forget debts. Your mortgage, car loans, credit card balances. All of that factors into the final equation.
3. Make a List (and Check It Twice)
Write everything down. Create categories like real estate, personal property, financial assets, and debts. Even if it seems tedious, this list becomes your north star for everything that follows.
Step 2: Legal Considerations – Know the Rules Before You Play
You don’t need a law degree to understand how divorce property settlement works in Canada, but a basic understanding of the rules will save you from surprises.
1. Provincial Differences Matter
Canada doesn’t have a one size fits all system. The rules for dividing assets differ by province or territory. In Ontario, for example, the law uses an equalization of net family property approach. In British Columbia, the Family Law Act lays out how assets are divided and what’s excluded.
The short version. Check your local laws or speak with a family lawyer to understand how your situation fits into the legal landscape.
2. Equal Isn’t Always 50 50
While the default goal is fairness, that doesn’t always mean a physical 50 50 split. One person might keep the house while the other gets a larger portion of the savings to balance things out. It’s about equal value, not necessarily equal items.
3. Protect Yourself with Paperwork
If you and your ex can reach an agreement on your own, that’s great. But make sure it’s in writing. A legal separation agreement formalizes your decisions and helps prevent future disputes. Always have it reviewed by a lawyer even if you drafted it yourselves to ensure it holds up in court if needed.
Step 3: Navigating Disagreements – When It Gets Tricky
Even if you're trying to keep things respectful, you’re both human. Disagreements are bound to happen, but they don’t have to derail the whole process.
1. Communicate Clearly (and Kindly)
It sounds obvious, but the way you communicate can make or break this process. Try to speak from a place of calm, not accusation.
Not so helpful: “You never cared about the condo anyway.”Much better: “The condo is important to me because I feel rooted here. Can we talk about how to make that work?”
Keep the conversation focused on solutions, not scorekeeping.
2. Mediation Can Be a Game Changer
When you just can’t agree, consider bringing in a neutral third party. Mediators are trained to help couples find middle ground without stepping into a courtroom.
Mediation is also more cost effective and usually quicker than litigation. Plus, it gives both parties more control over the outcome.
3. Choose Your Battles
It’s tempting to dig in on principle, but try to focus on what actually matters. Is it worth spending thousands in legal fees over a dining set you could replace for four hundred dollars at IKEA? Let logic take the wheel.
Pro Tips for Keeping Asset Division Simple (and Sane)
✅ Stay Organized Keep all financial documents in one place. Account statements, mortgage info, insurance policies, tax returns. It’ll make things smoother when it’s time to negotiate.
✅ Think Long Term Don’t just think about what feels fair today. Think about your future needs, especially when it comes to housing, income, and savings.
✅ Avoid Emotional Decisions Easier said than done, but try not to let hurt feelings influence major financial decisions. Keep the focus on fairness and what’s sustainable.
✅ Get the Right Support Friends, therapists, legal counsel, financial planners. You don’t have to do this alone. Lean on your people.
Closing Thoughts: Keep It Classy (and Clear)
Dividing assets in a divorce isn’t just about splitting things. It’s about creating space for both of you to move forward. Yes, there may be tension. Yes, it can feel overwhelming. But with clear communication, a little structure, and the willingness to keep it simple, you can make this chapter a little easier.
So channel your inner da Vinci. Simplicity really is the ultimate sophistication, and it might just be your secret weapon in navigating a divorce with grace and clarity.
Comments